COMPARISON


Van de Velde’s poster was designed in 1899 for Tropon food concentrate. Although it holds the title of first fully abstract poster, this was actually Van de Velde’s only poster of his career.  Not only did he design the poster for Tropon but he also created other materials and packaging for the company.  He emphasized abstract form by using abstract patterns.  The primary subject of the poster is a pattern of abstracted egg whites.

As Allegemein Elektricitats-Gesellschaft’s new artistic consultant, Behrens created a unified brand for the company. This included the design of anything from advertising materials to office buildings and factories.  In 1910, Van de Velde created a poster advertising AEG’s new light bulb.  This piece carries strong modernistic elements with its use of the basic geometric shapes laid out on a well-balanced grid.

Upon first glance it is easy to notice these two pieces of art have a similar hierarchy to one another.  Both have the company name displayed in the upper third, the product being advertised in the center of the composition, and additional text in the lower third.

The majority of each poster’s content is contained within a border.  For the Tropon poster, Van de Velde continued the abstract curvilinear lines from the egg whites as a transition into the uniform dark brown border that can be seen on the top and left of the image.  These curvilinear lines also create shapes throughout the main portion of the design.  The dark lines flowing through the egg whites divide it into more simplified shapes. Abstract shapes, but still more simplified.

Like Van de Velde’s border on the Tropon poster, a similar feature can be seen in Behren’s AEG poster.  Little repeating dots representing light make up the thin outlining border that contains the majority of this image within it.  Also similar to Van de Velde’s piece, Behren used his dotted lines to divide up the image space, creating simplified geometric forms.  It is interesting to note that in Van de Velde’s piece, the prominent color is a yellow while the diving lines are a dark brown.  In Behren’s piece it is the opposite.  Yellow borders divide the dark brown composition.

Both pieces have a strong sense of direction.  Although the Tropon poster is more abstracted in its form, like the AEG poster, it still has a downward motion.  Both pieces lead the viewer’s eye from the title of the company at the top, to the prominent product being advertised, down to the bottom blocks of color containing additional text.

Although these two pieces represent completely different styles they still poses many similar features.  This shows the underlying skill possessed by both artists. They hierarchy, shapes, and composition of both the Tropon poster by Henri Van de Velde and the AEG poster by Peter Brehens attribute to the success of the pieces and the artists alike.

Leave a Reply